How a Kitchen & Bath Contractor Increased Their Estimate Close Rate by 81.8% in 60 Days…by fixing the “Polite Maybe” problem (and firing the “Quote Collector” crowd)
I worked with a kitchen & bath contractor, in the suburbs of Denver, I can’t name because I operate under NDAs. I treat each client’s numbers, process, and competitive edge like protected assets. Confidentiality is non-negotiable.
So for this story, I’ll refer to them as “Stone & Slate.” You’ll get the full play-by-play, without any identifying details.
Stone & Slate had a frustrating situation:
Their marketing brought in decent leads… But their estimate pipeline felt like a revolving door:
- They’d do the site visit.
- They’d build a thoughtful quote.
- They’d send it over.
And then they’d get the same polite line:
“Thanks… we’ll think about it.”
Translation: “We’re collecting numbers. You’re one of three. Maybe four.”
If you’ve been in contracting long enough, you know the type.
- They don’t want a professional.
- They want a price.
And if you keep treating those people like real prospects, you don’t just lose deals… You lose time. You lose margin. You lose momentum.
Stone & Slate assumed the problem was price. Or lead quality. Or “the economy.”
But the real problem was simpler, and more brutal:
Their sales conversation made it easy to shop them.
They were acting like a helpful vendor…when they needed to act like a guide.
So I coached them through my Sales Conversion Accelerator, a question-led selling framework (NEPQ style) designed to do two things:
1. Expose who’s serious and who’s just collecting quotes
2. Create ownership of the problem and outcome before numbers enter the room
Once the homeowner owns the outcome, price is no longer the only factor they consider.
A few “stealable” changes we made:
- The 60-second opener that stopped “Just give me a ballpark.”
- The two questions that exposed “serious” vs “just browsing” in under a minute
- The decision checkpoint that cut quote ghosting
- Close language that felt direct (not pushy)
- A follow-up that forced a clean yes/no (without begging)
Here’s the play-by-play.
#1) We Found Where Estimates Were Dying (and why)
First, I had them review 20 recent opportunities and label exactly where deals stalled:
- Before the visit: low commitment / tire-kickers
- After the visit: comparison shopping
- After the quote: ghosting
- After “sleep on it”: no decision structure
Then we told the truth out loud:
Most losses didn’t happen because they were “too expensive.”
They lost because the homeowner never fully committed to fixing anything. So the quote felt optional, like a menu item.
Small change. Big impact.
Instead of ending with: “I’ll send the quote tonight.”
They switched to: “Perfect, when I send it, do you want to decide the same day, or do you need a couple of days to think it through?”
That one question did something magical:
- Serious people answered it
- Quote collectors avoided it
Either way, Stone & Slate stopped guessing.
#2) We Switched from “Explaining” to “Diagnosing”
Most contractors think selling means explaining.
- Explaining materials.
- Explaining the process.
- Explaining craftsmanship.
That’s fine, but here’s the problem: When you explain, homeowners compare you like on a spreadsheet.
So we rebuilt the conversation around a simple NEPQ flow:
- Problem: what’s not working in the current kitchen/bath
- Consequence: how it affects daily life (stress, function, embarrassment, time)
- Ownership: why it matters enough to fix now (not “someday”)
- Commitment: what a “right decision” looks like for them
This is the moment the homeowner stops acting like a shopper… And starts thinking like an owner.
One “quietly aggressive” question changed everything: “If nothing changes in the next 12 months… what does that cost you in frustration or inconvenience?”
Not dramatic.
Just unavoidable.
It makes procrastination feel expensive, which is exactly what it is.
#3) We Blocked Objections Before They Showed Up
Most contractors wait until after they send the quote to “handle objections.” That’s like putting a seatbelt on after the crash.
So Stone & Slate clarified decision criteria before pricing entered the room:
- Budget comfort zone (range, not interrogation)
- Timeline urgency (event, resale, family, daily pain)
- Who decides (spouse/partner/financing)
- What they compare (lowest price vs least hassle vs best design vs trust)
Tiny question. Massive leverage: “When you picture the finished space, what matters most: saving money, getting it done fast, or getting it done right so you don’t deal with it again?”
Now the homeowner tells you what they value. And once they say it out loud… they can’t unsay it.
#4) We Installed a Real Close (Instead of a Polite Exit)
Here’s the truth: Most homeowners don’t need more information.
They need a decision structure because decision-making is uncomfortable.
So we replaced the polite “I’ll send it over” with a direct frame:
“Based on what you told me, Option A fits your priorities best.
The only question is: are you ready to move forward, or do we need to tighten the plan so it feels like a clear yes?”
This does two things:
- It invites commitment
- It forces honesty
I
f they hesitate, you don’t argue about price.
You find the real friction.
#5) We Made Follow-Up Slightly Uncomfortable (in a respectful way)
Even with a strong conversation, some people still want “a day.”
Fine.
But we stopped letting “a day” turn into “never.”
So we gave them a follow-up cadence that created a clean fork in the road (Example text):
“Quick check-in: did you decide to move forward with the remodel plan, or did you put this on pause for now?”
Why it works:
- It gives two choices.
- Both require an answer.
And it makes ghosting feel awkward, without being rude.
Results (60 Days)
Once the conversation changed, the outcomes changed fast.
Over the next 60 days:
- Estimate close rate: ~22% → ~40% (+81.8%)
- Ghosting after quotes: down ~45% (more clear yes/no answers)
- Average job value: up ~18% (less discounting, stronger fit)
- Time wasted on non-buyers: dropped sharply (better pre-frame + filtering)
- Sales cycle: shortened (more same-week decisions)
The owner told me:
“We didn’t change our craftsmanship; we changed the conversation. And suddenly we’re closing people who used to ‘think about it’ forever.”
The Takeaway
This wasn’t a “better script.”
This was a better filter and a better process.
When you stop presenting quotes like a vendor and start leading decisions like a guide, you stop competing on price.
You start competing on certainty.
That’s the power of the Sales Conversion Accelerator when you install it correctly.
⬇️ If you’re tired of “quote” shoppers and want better leads + higher closes, book your FREE 15-Minute Chaos-to-Clarity Strategy Huddle. ⬇️
Your FREE 15-Minute Chaos-to-Clarity Strategy Huddle
STEP #1 - BOOK YOUR FREE HUDDLE
Benefit: Immediately spot your #1 roadblock (sales, marketing, or operations) in 15 minutes, risk-free.
STEP #2 - GET YOUR CUSTOM ACTION PLAN
Benefit: Walk away with a clear 3-step action plan of what script to use, what metric to track, and what system to install first.
STEP #3 - ACHIEVE PREDICTABLE PROFIT
Benefit: Implement the systematic framework to gain predictable revenue, end chaos, and finally win your time back.
The Transformation: From Trapped Owner to Free Leader.
We help home service owners stop running chaos and achieve predictable profitability and true time freedom. You will move from being confused and ill-equipped to being a competent and confident leader who knows how to scale without sacrificing their personal life.
Quick Links
Home
About
Book a Consultation
Connect
© Olsen Strategic Advisors LLC
All Rights Reserved 2025